IAA Ignite fires up and hotly debates burning question
Everywhere in the world, the burning question in people’s minds is ‘Who Owns The Brand? Marketer or Consumer?’.
This was, to a degree, answered at the joint International Advertising Association (Malaysia chapter) and Dentsu Aegis Network event, IAA Ignite, on Wednesday 17 May 2017 at the Pavilion Sports Bar & Brassiere, Royal Lake Club in Kuala Lumpur.
After the resounding success of the inaugural IAA Ignite in November 2016, which carried the theme ‘Is The Newspaper Immortal?’, this second Panel Debate-Social Networking session had the thought provoking ‘Who Owns The Brand? Marketer or Consumer’ as its theme.
IAA Exco with the debate panellists: (L-R) Mahmood Razak, Chacko Vadaketh, Andreas Vogiatzakis, Bharat Avalani (IAA Malaysia Honorary Advisor), Omar Shaari (CEO, Dentsu One and IAA Malaysia Vice President), John Chacko, Prabha Nayar, Prashant Kumar, Nicky Lim (CEO, Dentsu Aegis Network Malaysia), Tanvi Singh, Sue-Anne Lim, Ng Li Lian (Head of Retail, Sime Darby Auto Connexion JLR and IAA Malaysia Honorary Treasurer) and Harmandar Singh.
Moderated by Harmandar Singh (Founder & Regional CEO of ADOI and Marketing magazines, and Honorary Advisor of IAA Malaysia), the two teams comprised an admirable panel of luminaries from across diverse backgrounds.
Team ‘Marketer’ was headed by Prashant Kumar (Founder & Senior Partner, Entropia), with team mates, Sue-Anne Lim (Chief Data Officer, Dentsu Aegis Network Malaysia) and Tanvi Singh (Lead Strategist, Isobar Malaysia).
Team ‘Consumer’ was led by Andreas Vogiatzakis (Head, Havas Media), with team mates, Chacko Vadaketh (Lawyer turned Theatre-Television-Radio-Public Personality) and Mahmood Razak (Group Head, Strategic Communications Division, DRB-HICOM)
In his introduction, John D. Chacko (President, IAA Malaysia) remarked that, “In essence, the question is not about who owns the brand, but more about whether the brand is fulfilling the brand promise. But since ownership remains such a burning question in everyone’s minds, let the two teams state their case and let the audience decide.
He continued, “Consumers remember the promise of the brand and when the brand breaks that promise, they have the power in the palm of their hands to tell the world”.
“In recent memory, the United Airlines kerfuffle is a case study, in where, the brand, United Airlines was perceived to have broken its brand promise of ‘come fly the friendly skies’. Within hours, that brand promise ended up a contradiction as judged by the hundreds of millions who watched the infamous video around the world. In this age of digital advocacy, ‘it’s not what you say, it’s what they say’. Consumers can make or break a brand”, Chacko emphasised.
Harmandar Singh, better known as Ham, deftly handled the teams with a balance of patience, persuasion and dead-pan humour.
Attended by almost 100 personalities from in and out of the marketing communications industry, the evening’s theme resonated well with the audience.
“Visionary marketers lead the consumer, not follow them. Consumers don’t wish to take accountability for the brand. They can’t be owners. Marketers are responsible for the brands, so they are the owners, not just in letters but also in spirit. There is a social contract between the consumer and the brand, based on a value exchange against a certain price. If you break that contract, if you break that trust, consumers have a megaphone today and they will not sit quiet”, said Prashant Kumar in driving home the ‘Marketer’ stance.
“Today, two out of three people in the world are connected into social network, which makes 3.5billion independent media owners out there. 80% of consumers say they trust peer comments and recommendations on social media and only 20% trust advertising. This new social power allows the consumer to be the brand custodian”, countered Andreas Vogiatzakis.
Sue-Anne Lim, put forward, “Today, marketers have access to consumer intelligence and voice in a scale never-before, and the smart ones will utilise these insights to foretell what consumers want and don’t want, to continuously improvise brand marketing. To abdicate the entire marketing decision and shift the ownership to consumers is not just non-visionary, it’s plain lazy! Consumers are important and active consultants to marketers, but they certainly do not own the brand”.
“Marketer is more of a custodian for the brand. The consumer decides if he wants to use the brand and effectively claim ownership of it. The consumer has the brand in his hands. He can evaluate it through a variety of means easily at his disposal, and decide for himself, regardless of what the marketer may tell him”, responded Chacko Vadaketh
Stressing her point, Tanvi Singh said, “Social media is now a power play where consumers want to exert dominance over brands who fail on their brand promises. No way does this mean consumers want ownership of the brand. Rather, it’s a phenomenon which is bringing new equilibrium to the brand-consumer equation”.
An interesting quip came from Mahmood Razak, citing an example of English football, which many Malaysians are passionate about.
“In their 2013-2014 Premiership season, the 1899-established Cardiff City, nicknamed the Bluebirds, now under a new owner, changed their look from the traditional Bluebirds blue kit to a dragon logo red kit. Fans were livid, with protests via banners, booing, skipping matches, even switching allegiances. The owner was forced to revert to the legendary blue kit in the 2015-2016 season, by which time, Cardiff was back in the Championship. Don’t mess with the sanctity of brand! The owner is the ‘legal owner’ of the ‘brand’, but the brand is actually ‘owned’ by the fans”, said Mahmood.
After being entertained by the fiery sessions, the audience voted the ‘Marketer’ team had put forward a more persuasive argument.
This event saw Dentsu Aegis Network Malaysia as Partner, and M&C Saatchi, Media Prima, Marketing, Jaguar Land Rover, JDC Brand Truth and Visual Retale as Supporters.
IAA Malaysia’s purpose for being is to connect, inform and represent the marketing communications community, with primary focus on knowledge and learning and networking.
With calls to have events such as this more often, IAA Malaysia has earmarked one exciting event every quarter.
Now on an active membership drive, queries on membership can be channelled to firstname.lastname@example.org
IAA, headquartered in New York, was established in 1938 and now has a presence in over 76 countries.
Click on the following URL for the article on The Star. 170520_Star_IAA Ignite fires up
- IAA Ignite Panel Debate 28 August 2018 : Big brands are doomed to oblivion. Lessons from GE14
- International Advertising Association celebrates 80th Anniversary with new direction.
- ‘Does Creativity Pay?’ stimulates strong opinions at IAA Ignite Debate Series
- IAA Ignite Panel Debate 5 Oct 2017 : Creativity Doesn’t Pay. The Great IP Debate.
- 20 years of Publishing Excellence
- Friends of Friends by the IAA 4 July 2017
- IAA Ignite fires up and hotly debates burning question
- IAA Ignite Panel Debate 17 May 2017 : Who owns the brand? Marketer or consumer?
- IAA Elects New EXCO for 2017/18
- Wine & Cheese Evening 23 Feb 2017
- Notice of AGM to be held on 30 March 2017
- IAA Ignite Panel Debate 30 Nov 2016 : Is the Newspaper Immortal?
- Notice of AGM to be held on 18 March 2015
- Notice of EGM to be held on 28 April 2014
- Notice of AGM to be held on 26 March 2014
- The Inside Track
- IAA celebrates 75 years
- 75th IAA Anniversary Social
- IAA Malaysia Elects New Exco
- AGM to be held on 28 March 2013